Retirement
Retail v industry: Is the super performance gap worrying?
Data released by APRA this week has shown the gap between average annual returns between retail super funds and their industry fund peers has widened, but should members be concerned?
Retail v industry: Is the super performance gap worrying?
Data released by APRA this week has shown the gap between average annual returns between retail super funds and their industry fund peers has widened, but should members be concerned?
Earlier this week the prudential regulator published its superannuation statistics for June 2017, which lobby group Industry Super Australia (ISA) said highlighted a disturbing trend.
David Whiteley, the chief executive of ISA, said the gap in performance between not-for-profit industry super funds and their bank-owned retail peers was growing, according to the data released by APRA.
“It is well known that not-for-profit industry super funds dominate the performance league tables. Less known is the apparent widening performance gap between industry and retail super funds,” he said.
ISA’s analysis of the June statistics found that industry funds outperformed retail funds by 2.13 per cent over five years, 2.44 per cent over three years, and 2.89 per cent over one.
“For those Australians who entrust their savings to a bank-owned super fund, the trend is alarming,” he said.
“For the average income earner a 2 per cent performance gap may be a difference of around $200,000 at retirement. The new figures show the performance gap edging dangerously close to 3 per cent”.
Mr Whiteley said fund members and policy makers should be concerned by this and look at how cross-selling and profit flows within the retail fund market affects returns.
However, the Financial Services Council (FSC), the lobby group representing retail funds, told Nest Egg the data doesn’t tell the whole story, and that the use of averages can actually mask individual fund performance.
“Averages are misleading and the fund level data often cited is even more so,” a spokesperson for the FSC said.
“It includes all the investment options offered by retail platforms, including low yielding cash and bonds; which are designed to protect capital rather than post stellar returns.”
The spokesperson said that APRA’s calculations even found the performance of MySuper products across both the retail and industry segments was “broadly equal” and policy makers faced more pressing issues.
“As you would expect, there are some strongly performing industry funds and strongly performing retail funds. There are also poorly performing funds in both categories,” the spokesperson said.
“The challenge for policy makers should be enabling people to switch from a poor fund to a better fund, regardless of whether they are industry or retail.”
According to APRA’s data, the best performing fund in the two segments of the market was a retail fund, with a net investment return of 3.57 per cent, followed by an industry fund with a net investment return of 3.56 per cent.
However, the data also showed the worst performing fund in the two market segments was a retail fund with net investment return of 0.58 per cent, while the worst performing industry fund delivered a net investment return of 1 per cent.
RELATED ARTICLES
Superannuation
Aware Super elevates tech leadership with strategic appointment of Richard Exton
Aware Super, one of Australia's largest industry super funds, has announced a pivotal appointment to its executive team, underscoring the growing importance of technology, data, and artificial ...Read more
Superannuation
Rest appoints Marina Pasika as interim head of private markets
Rest, one of Australia's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has announced the appointment of Marina Pasika as the Interim Head of Private Markets. This decision comes as the fund embarks ...Read more
Superannuation
Payday Super bill introduces new challenges for SMBs, reveals Employment Hero CEO
The introduction of the Payday Super bill to the Australian Parliament has sparked a significant response from the business community, particularly among small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs)Read more
Superannuation
Rest urges Parliament to expedite payday super legislation
In a significant move towards enhancing retirement outcomes for Australian workers, Rest, one of the country's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has expressed strong support for the ...Read more
Superannuation
Recalibrated super performance test aims to enhance accountability and investment opportunities
In a move that signals a shift rather than a cessation, Australia's government has announced a targeted review of the superannuation performance test. This recalibration, prompted by the latest ...Read more
Superannuation
Super performance test faces a fork balancing member value productive investment and regulatory trust
APRA’s latest superannuation performance test results have reignited a high‑stakes debate: does the test optimise member value or unintentionally curb long‑term investment in housing, infrastructure ...Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super unveils innovative digital tool to boost retirees' financial confidence
Aware Super has unveiled a groundbreaking digital advice tool, Retirement Manager, designed to empower retirees by addressing their most pressing financial concerns. Developed in collaboration with ...Read more
Superannuation
APRA's super shake-up: Balancing accountability and innovation in the next round
Australia’s performance test has forced long-overdue transparency in super and accelerated consolidation. But as the regime broadens, its blunt edges are colliding with investment complexity, ESG ...Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super elevates tech leadership with strategic appointment of Richard Exton
Aware Super, one of Australia's largest industry super funds, has announced a pivotal appointment to its executive team, underscoring the growing importance of technology, data, and artificial ...Read more
Superannuation
Rest appoints Marina Pasika as interim head of private markets
Rest, one of Australia's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has announced the appointment of Marina Pasika as the Interim Head of Private Markets. This decision comes as the fund embarks ...Read more
Superannuation
Payday Super bill introduces new challenges for SMBs, reveals Employment Hero CEO
The introduction of the Payday Super bill to the Australian Parliament has sparked a significant response from the business community, particularly among small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs)Read more
Superannuation
Rest urges Parliament to expedite payday super legislation
In a significant move towards enhancing retirement outcomes for Australian workers, Rest, one of the country's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has expressed strong support for the ...Read more
Superannuation
Recalibrated super performance test aims to enhance accountability and investment opportunities
In a move that signals a shift rather than a cessation, Australia's government has announced a targeted review of the superannuation performance test. This recalibration, prompted by the latest ...Read more
Superannuation
Super performance test faces a fork balancing member value productive investment and regulatory trust
APRA’s latest superannuation performance test results have reignited a high‑stakes debate: does the test optimise member value or unintentionally curb long‑term investment in housing, infrastructure ...Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super unveils innovative digital tool to boost retirees' financial confidence
Aware Super has unveiled a groundbreaking digital advice tool, Retirement Manager, designed to empower retirees by addressing their most pressing financial concerns. Developed in collaboration with ...Read more
Superannuation
APRA's super shake-up: Balancing accountability and innovation in the next round
Australia’s performance test has forced long-overdue transparency in super and accelerated consolidation. But as the regime broadens, its blunt edges are colliding with investment complexity, ESG ...Read more
