Retirement
Does Australia really need compulsory super?
Making superannuation opt-in rather than compulsory could have huge ramifications for everyday Australians, despite a NSW senator seeing the option as a win-win for low-income earners and the government.
Does Australia really need compulsory super?
Making superannuation opt-in rather than compulsory could have huge ramifications for everyday Australians, despite a NSW senator seeing the option as a win-win for low-income earners and the government.
In his maiden speech, newly elected NSW senator Andrew Bragg brought up the idea that superannuation should be an opt-in system rather than compulsory, citing the adoption of such a change being capable of bringing big savings to the government.
He remarked that “super should be made voluntary for Australians earning under $50,000”.
According to his option, “taxpayers could simply tick a box to get a refund when filing an annual tax return”.
Mr Bragg said he had commissioned modelling from Rice Warner actuaries in considering such a reform, “which estimates a saving to government of $1.8 billion in the first year alone”.
Helping Australians get their first home
The senator said that the removal of superannuation as a compulsory aspect of salary would make it easier for Australians to own their first home, with many currently priced out of the market.
“Super is making home ownership so much harder for lower-income Australians. The CIS found that the average deposit for a first home has doubled between 2000 and 2015. Since super started in 1992, every single age group has experienced lower levels of home ownership,” Mr Bragg highlighted.
Does the maths stack up?
Industry Super Australia analysis said that removal of the compulsory super contribution for a person on $50,000 a year, would simply contribute to a higher personal income tax bill.
It said this could see an individual paying an additional $1,710 a year in tax, which is an increase of nearly $1,000 on money that would otherwise be in their super account.
“Any claim that this would ‘save’ $1.8 billion conveniently ignores the fact that wages are taxed at a higher rate than superannuation – meaning this would actually cost low-income workers more in the long run,” Industry Super Australia said.
Industry Super Australia chief executive Bernie Dean commented that “this extreme plan will see low-income workers pay more tax only to end up with less money at retirement”.
“Taking away compulsory super for low-income earners would condemn some of our most vulnerable Australians to poverty in retirement,” continued Mr Dean.
Calling it a “flawed plan”, such a change would see low-income workers pay more tax for less money at retirement, Industry Super Australia said, while everyone will foot the bill as dependence on the pension increases.
RELATED ARTICLES
About the author
About the author
Superannuation
Small businesses brace for cash flow challenges as Payday Super becomes law
With the new Payday Super legislation now enacted, small businesses across Australia are preparing for a significant shift in how they manage superannuation contributions. The law, which mandates a ...Read more
Superannuation
Rest launches Innovate RAP to support fairer super outcomes for First Nations members
In a significant move towards reconciliation and inclusivity, Rest, one of Australia's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has unveiled its Innovate Reconciliation Action Plan (RAP)Read more
Superannuation
Payday super legislation promises fairer retirement for part-time and casual workers
In a landmark development for the Australian workforce, the recently passed Payday Super legislation is set to transform the retirement landscape for countless part-time and casual workersRead more
Superannuation
Payday Super passes as Employment Hero, OZEDI and Zepto unite to help small businesses meet new seven-day payment rule
With the Payday Superannuation Bill officially passing through Parliament, Australian businesses are now less than eight months away from a major shift in how superannuation contributions are made — ...Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super appoints Simon Warner as Chief Investment Officer
Aware Super has announced the appointment of Simon Warner as Chief Investment Officer, effective 1 December 2025, following a competitive global search to replace outgoing CIO Damian Graham, who ...Read more
Superannuation
Employers call for pragmatic safeguards to ensure Payday Super reform succeeds
Employment Hero chief executive Ben Thompson has urged the federal government to introduce a phased rollout and reciprocal safeguards to support small businesses as the Payday Super reform approaches ...Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super elevates tech leadership with strategic appointment of Richard Exton
Aware Super, one of Australia's largest industry super funds, has announced a pivotal appointment to its executive team, underscoring the growing importance of technology, data, and artificial ...Read more
Superannuation
Rest appoints Marina Pasika as interim head of private markets
Rest, one of Australia's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has announced the appointment of Marina Pasika as the Interim Head of Private Markets. This decision comes as the fund embarks ...Read more
Superannuation
Small businesses brace for cash flow challenges as Payday Super becomes law
With the new Payday Super legislation now enacted, small businesses across Australia are preparing for a significant shift in how they manage superannuation contributions. The law, which mandates a ...Read more
Superannuation
Rest launches Innovate RAP to support fairer super outcomes for First Nations members
In a significant move towards reconciliation and inclusivity, Rest, one of Australia's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has unveiled its Innovate Reconciliation Action Plan (RAP)Read more
Superannuation
Payday super legislation promises fairer retirement for part-time and casual workers
In a landmark development for the Australian workforce, the recently passed Payday Super legislation is set to transform the retirement landscape for countless part-time and casual workersRead more
Superannuation
Payday Super passes as Employment Hero, OZEDI and Zepto unite to help small businesses meet new seven-day payment rule
With the Payday Superannuation Bill officially passing through Parliament, Australian businesses are now less than eight months away from a major shift in how superannuation contributions are made — ...Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super appoints Simon Warner as Chief Investment Officer
Aware Super has announced the appointment of Simon Warner as Chief Investment Officer, effective 1 December 2025, following a competitive global search to replace outgoing CIO Damian Graham, who ...Read more
Superannuation
Employers call for pragmatic safeguards to ensure Payday Super reform succeeds
Employment Hero chief executive Ben Thompson has urged the federal government to introduce a phased rollout and reciprocal safeguards to support small businesses as the Payday Super reform approaches ...Read more
Superannuation
Aware Super elevates tech leadership with strategic appointment of Richard Exton
Aware Super, one of Australia's largest industry super funds, has announced a pivotal appointment to its executive team, underscoring the growing importance of technology, data, and artificial ...Read more
Superannuation
Rest appoints Marina Pasika as interim head of private markets
Rest, one of Australia's largest profit-to-member superannuation funds, has announced the appointment of Marina Pasika as the Interim Head of Private Markets. This decision comes as the fund embarks ...Read more
