Invest
Does bitcoin now fit the accounting definition of cash?
With bitcoin being declared legal tender in El Salvador and more generally gaining acceptance as a transaction currency across the world, does this cryptocurrency now meet the definition of cash, as outlined by the Australian Accounting Standards Board and other standard-setters around the world?
Does bitcoin now fit the accounting definition of cash?
With bitcoin being declared legal tender in El Salvador and more generally gaining acceptance as a transaction currency across the world, does this cryptocurrency now meet the definition of cash, as outlined by the Australian Accounting Standards Board and other standard-setters around the world?
In Australia, cash and cash equivalents are defined in reporting standards (AASB 107) as the following:
• Cash comprises cash on hand and demand deposits.
• Cash equivalents are short-term, highly liquid investments that are readily convertible to known amounts of cash and which are subject to an insignificant risk in changes in value.
What is interesting here is that the definition of cash above is quite broad – there are no limitations on what currency this cash may be in – be it the Ukrainian hryvnia, Libyan dinar or Danish krone. Even the Argentinian peso or Turkish lira, with those countries’ currencies rapidly falling in value due to their underlying hyperinflationary environments, meet this definition of cash.
So here is where the bitcoin question becomes troublesome.
Across the world, regulators are wary of entities transacting in bitcoin, and under the definition above, there is broad consensus that a cryptocurrency is not cash per se, principally due to its high levels of volatility but also as it (previously) has not been legal tender of any country.
Now that it is legal tender of a country and thus bypasses the volatility restriction built into the cash equivalents definition, should it now be considered cash under AASB 107?
Some standard-setters have commented on this issue, citing that cash in their interpretation should be readily exchanged for goods or services. But here is where things get murky – I may have $600 Suriname dollars, and I may only be able to purchase goods and services with those dollars only after a long flight to South America. Does this mean that those Suriname dollars are not cash? How can the standard-setters determine which currencies are in and which are out for defining what cash is?
This process could become a political nightmare.
To overcome this, the standard-setters may seek to narrow down the definition of cash with a rules-based approach, perhaps defining cash according to:
• Levels of trade in the currency
• Volatility against established fiat currencies of the world
These, too, would be problematic – as an example, bitcoin is traded far more extensively than many currencies around the world. Meanwhile accounting standard-setters like the International Accounting Standards Board or the US-based Financial Accounting Standards Board (the FASB) are yet to provide any colour on this issue.
Practitioners are now wondering:
• Is there a rebuttable presumption that a currency automatically cash? And if so,
• What circumstances (i.e. trade levels, volatility, underlying inflation) may exist where that rebuttable presumption fails?
The recent development in El Salvador, where bitcoin is now legal tender and a currency highlights that this is an issue that the standard-setters can no longer ignore. For the time being, those entities based in El Salvador using only bitcoin will need to continue to file cashless financial reports under both IFRS and US GAAP financial reporting principles.
Nicholas Benbow is the director, audit and assurance at William Buck.
RELATED ARTICLES
Bitcoin
Aussie bitcoin mining startup smashes pre-seed funding record
An Aussie bitcoin mining startup has raised $2.6 million in pre-seed funding, setting an Australian record. Read more
Bitcoin
Blockchain tipped to ‘irreversibly’ shake up global payments system
Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are reaching the point of critical mass, an expert has said. Read more
Bitcoin
Bitcoin’s death cross descent may just be the beginning
Some bitcoin backers are jumping at the chance to gain from recent losses in the cryptocurrency market. Read more
Bitcoin
Goldman Sachs says bitcoin could hit US$100k despite recent losses
Inflation could drive the price of bitcoin to new heights. Read more
Bitcoin
Bitcoin records worst monthly performance since May
The world’s most popular cryptocurrency has ended a tumultuous 2021 on a sour note. Read more
Bitcoin
Panic-sellers offer bitcoin backers a Christmas bargain
Bitcoin’s latest losses could bolster the long-term gains of true crypto believers. Read more
Bitcoin
Aussies are already paying their bills in bitcoin
Getting paid and paying bills in bitcoin may just be a matter of time. Read more
Bitcoin
China loses lead on bitcoin mining
China is no longer the biggest contributor to the global hashrate. Read more
Bitcoin
Aussie bitcoin mining startup smashes pre-seed funding record
An Aussie bitcoin mining startup has raised $2.6 million in pre-seed funding, setting an Australian record. Read more
Bitcoin
Blockchain tipped to ‘irreversibly’ shake up global payments system
Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are reaching the point of critical mass, an expert has said. Read more
Bitcoin
Bitcoin’s death cross descent may just be the beginning
Some bitcoin backers are jumping at the chance to gain from recent losses in the cryptocurrency market. Read more
Bitcoin
Goldman Sachs says bitcoin could hit US$100k despite recent losses
Inflation could drive the price of bitcoin to new heights. Read more
Bitcoin
Bitcoin records worst monthly performance since May
The world’s most popular cryptocurrency has ended a tumultuous 2021 on a sour note. Read more
Bitcoin
Panic-sellers offer bitcoin backers a Christmas bargain
Bitcoin’s latest losses could bolster the long-term gains of true crypto believers. Read more
Bitcoin
Aussies are already paying their bills in bitcoin
Getting paid and paying bills in bitcoin may just be a matter of time. Read more
Bitcoin
China loses lead on bitcoin mining
China is no longer the biggest contributor to the global hashrate. Read more
